Citizenship-as-competence, what else? Why European citizenship education policy threatens to fall short of its aims

Bellamy, R (2008) Evaluating Union citizenship: Belonging, rights and participation within the EU. Citizenship Studies 12(6): 597–611.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Biesta, G (2009a) Good education in an age of measurement: On the need to reconnect with the question of purpose in education. Educational Assessment, Evaluation and Accountability 21(1): 33–46.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Biesta, G (2009b) What kind of citizenship for European higher education? Beyond the competent active citizen. European Educational Research Journal 8(2): 146–158.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Biesta, G (2010) A new logic of emancipation: The methodology of Jacques Rancière. Educational Theory 60(1): 39–59.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Biesta, G, Simons, M (2009) Higher education and European citizenship as a matter of public concern. European Educational Research Journal 8(2): 142–145.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Bîrzéa, C, Kerr, D, Mikkelsen, R, et al. (2004) All European study on education for democratic citizenship policies. Strasbourg. Council of Europe Publishing. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/16802f7040 (accessed 19 October 2019).
Google Scholar

Council of Europe (2010) Council of Europe Charter on Education for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights Education: Recommendation CM/rec (2010) adopted by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on 11 May 2010 and explanatory memorandum. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/16803034e3 (accessed 21 January 2019).
Google Scholar

Council of Europe (2017) Learning to live together. Council of Europe report on the state of citizenship and human rights education in Europe. June. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/the-state-of-citizenship-in-europe-e-publication/168072b3cd (accessed 1 February 2019).
Google Scholar

Council of Europe (2018) Reference framework of competences for democratic culture. Volume 1: Context, concepts and models. April. Council of Europe Publishing. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/prems-008318-gbr-2508-reference-framework-of-competences-vol-1-8573-co/16807bc66c (accessed 18 January 2019).
Google Scholar

Council of the European Union (2018) EU priorities for cooperation with the Council of Europe in 2018–2019. 22 January. Brussels. Available at: https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/eu-priorities-cooperation-coe-2018-2019_en.pdf (accessed 22 September 2020).
Google Scholar

Delanty, R (1998) Dilemmas of citizenship: Recent literature on citizenship and Europe. Citizenship Studies 2(2): 353–358.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Dimitrov, G, Boyadjieva, P (2009) Citizenship education as an instrument for strengthening the state’s supremacy: An apparent paradox? Citizenship Studies 13(2): 153–169.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Emler, N, Frazer, E (1999) Politics: The education effect. Oxford Review of Education 25(1–2): 251–273.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI

European Commission (2015) Declaration on Promoting citizenship and the common values of freedom, tolerance and non-discrimination through education. 17 March. Paris. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/assets/eac/education/news/2015/documents/citizenship-education-declaration_en.pdf (accessed 13 September 2019).
Google Scholar

European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice (2012) Citizenship Education in Europe. May. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/citizenship/pdf/citizenship_education_in_europe_en.pdf (accessed 13 September 2019).
Google Scholar

European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice (2017) Citizenship education at school in Europe – 2017. Eurydice Report. October. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Available at: https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/6b50c5b0-d651-11e7-a506-01aa75ed71a1/language-en/format-PDF/source-56573425 (accessed 2 September 2020).
Google Scholar

Fischman, GE, Haas, E (2014) Moving beyond idealistically narrow discourses in citizenship education. Policy Futures in Education 12(3): 387–402.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Gifford, C, Gonçalves, S, Wolodzko, E, et al. (2010) Post-national citizenship and higher education in the European Union. European Political Science 9(3): 341–357.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Heater, DB (1999) What is Citizenship?. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Google Scholar

Heater, D (2002) The history of citizenship education: A comparative outline. Parliamentary Affairs 55(3): 457–474.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Hodgson, N (2016) Citizenship for the Learning Society. Europe, Subjectivity, and Educational Research. Hoboken: Wiley.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Hummrich, M (2018) Education for Europe? Professionalization between effectiveness and autonomy. European Educational Research Journal 17(6): 784–792.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI

Ioannidou, A (2007) A comparative analysis of new governance in the transnational educational space: A shift to knowledge-based instruments? European Educational Research Journal 6(4): 336–347.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Joppke, C (2007) Beyond national models: Civic integration policies for immigrants in Western Europe. West European Politics 30(1): 1–22.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI

Joris, M, Agirdag, O (2019) In search of good citizenship education: A normative analysis of the International Civic and Citizenship Education Study (ICCS). European Journal of Education 54(2): 287–298.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Keating, A (2009) Educating Europe’s citizens: Moving from national to post-national models of educating for European citizenship. Citizenship Studies 13(2): 135–151.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI

Keating, A (2014) Education for Citizenship in Europe: European Policies, National Adaptations, and Young People’s Attitudes. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Lawy, R, Biesta, G (2006) Citizenship-as-practice: The educational implications of an inclusive and relational understanding of citizenship. British Journal of Educational Studies 54(1): 34–50.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI

Lock, G, Martins, H (2009) The European universities, citizenship and its limits: What won’t solve the problems of our time. European Educational Research Journal 8(2): 159–174.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Löden, H, McCallion, MS, Wall, P (2014) Teaching citizenship: What if the EU is part of the solution and not the problem? Journal of Political Science Education 10(4): 386–399.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Masschelein, J, Simons, M (2009) From active citizenship to world citizenship: A proposal for a world university. European Educational Research Journal 8(2): 236–248.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Maurissen, L, Claes, E, Barber, C (2018) Deliberation in citizenship education: How the school context contributes to the development of an open classroom climate. Social Psychology of Education 21(4): 951–972.
Google Scholar | Crossref

McCowan, T (2009) A ‘seamless’ enactment of citizenship education. Journal of Philosophy of Education 43(1): 85–99.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI

Merry, M (2020) Can schools teach citizenship? Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 41(1): 124–138.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Naval, C, Print, M, Veldhuis, R (2002) Education for democratic citizenship in the new Europe: Context and reform. European Journal of Education 37(2): 107–128.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Nicoll, K, Fejes, A, Olson, M, et al. (2013) Opening discourses of citizenship education: A theorization with Foucault. Journal of Education Policy 28(6): 828–846.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Nordensvärd, J (2014) The politics of education: Education from a political and citizenship discourse. Policy Futures in Education 12(3): 340–346.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Olson, M (2012) To be or not to be a (properly educated) citizen. Comments on the ICCS 2009 study. Utbildning & Demokrati 21(1): 17–27.
Google Scholar

Print, M, Ørnstrøm, S, Nielsen, HS (2002) Education for democratic processes in schools and classrooms. European Journal of Education 37(2): 193–210.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Pykett, J, Saward, M, Schaefer, A (2010) Framing the good citizen. British Journal of Politics & International Relations 12(4): 523–538.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI

Rutkowski, D, Engel, LC (2010) Soft power and hard measures: Large-scale assessment, citizenship and the European Union. European Educational Research Journal 9(3): 381–395.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals

Rømer, TA (2020) Gert Biesta – Education between Bildung and post-structuralism. Educational Philosophy and Theory 53(1): 34–45.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Säfström, CA (2011) Rethinking emancipation, rethinking education. Studies in Philosophy and Education 30(2): 199–209.
Google Scholar | Crossref | ISI

Schugurensky, D (2005) Citizenship and citizenship education: Canada in an international context. Available at: http://fcis.oise.utoronto.ca/~daniel_schugurensky/lclp/c&ce.html (accessed 15 September 2019).
Google Scholar

Schulz, W, Ainley, J, Fraillon, J, et al. (2018) Becoming citizens in a changing world. IEA International Civic and Citizenship Education Study 2016 International Report. Springer Open. Available at https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007%2F978-3-319-73963-2 (accessed 20 October 2019).
Google Scholar

Siim, B (2013) Citizenship. In: Waylen, G, Celis, K, Kantola, J, et al (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Gender and Politics (Ch. 7). Retrieved from Oxford Handbooks Online.
Google Scholar

Simons, M, Hodgson, N (2012) Learned voices of European citizens: From governmental to political subjectivation. Teoría de la educación. Revista Universitaria 24(1): 19–40.
Google Scholar

Simons, M, Masschelein, J (2010) Governmental, political and pedagogic subjectivation: Foucault with Rancière. Educational Philosophy and Theory 42(5–6): 588–605.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Simons, M, Olssen, M, Peters, MA (eds) (2009) Re-reading Education Policies. A Handbook Studying the Policy Agenda of the 21st Century. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Telling, K, Serapioni, M (2019) The rise and change of the competence strategy: Reflections on twenty-five years of skills policies in the EU. European Educational Research Journal 18(4): 387–406.
Google Scholar | SAGE Journals | ISI

Walkenhorst, H (2008) Explaining change in EU education policy. Journal of European Public Policy 15(4): 567–587.
Google Scholar | Crossref

Wihlborg, M (2019) Critical viewpoints on the Bologna Process in Europe: Can we do otherwise? European Educational Research Journal 18(2): 135–157.
Google Scholar

Zurstrassen, B (2011) A sceptical look at the quantitative education research in civic and citizenship education. Journal of Social Science Education 10(3): 6–15.
Google Scholar